In all cases, the prospective Rider must first be a current member, in good standing, in one of the three organizations of The American Legion Family: The American Legion, The American Legion Auxiliary, or The Sons of The American Legion.

The American Legion Riders have also adopted the following basic eligibility rules for membership:

1. All members of the American Legion Riders must hold individual membership in The American Legion, The American Legion Auxiliary, or the Sons of The American Legion.
2. Members must be the legally registered owner of a motorcycle or be the spouse of a properly insured motorcycle of at least 350cc engine displacement and possess a valid motorcycle driver's license in their state of residence (military equivalents acceptable as well).
3. All operators must be properly licensed and insured per state laws
4. All members will obey the motor vehicle laws in any state in which they are operating a motorcycle or riding as a passenger.